Metal Roof vs Shingles: Which is the Best Choice for Your Home?

When it comes to choosing the best roofing material for your home, the debate between metal roof vs shingles is one of the most common. Your roof is a significant investment, and selecting the right material affects not just the cost but also the longevity, durability, and energy efficiency of your home.

Should you go for a classic asphalt shingle roof or opt for a more modern metal roofing system? Which one offers the best return on investment? And most importantly, which one fits your budget?

For many homeowners, the debate comes down to metal roof vs asphalt shingles. Both are popular choices, but they offer stark differences in terms of cost, lifespan, energy efficiency, and maintenance. Whether you’re building a new home or replacing an old roof, this blog will compare these two options side by side, empowering you to make a well informed decision.

Understanding Metal Roofs and Shingle Roofs

What Are Metal Roofs?

They are made from materials like aluminum, steel, zinc, or copper, and are designed to last decades. These roofs are sleek, modern, and incredibly durable, making them an increasingly popular roofing choice among homeowners.

Key Benefits:

• Durability: They can withstand extreme weather, including heavy snow, hurricanes, and wildfires. 
  
• Energy Efficiency: Metal roofing panels reflect sunlight, reducing cooling costs during hot months. 
  
• Modern Design: Available in various styles and colors for contemporary aesthetics.
  

However, the upfront metal roof material cost and installation prices tend to be higher, which often makes homeowners hesitant.

What Are Shingle Roofs?

Shingle roofs consist of overlapping asphalt layers reinforced with fiberglass for durability. Known for their classic appeal and affordability, metal shingles roofing have long been the go to choice for suburban and traditional homes.

Key Benefits of Shingle Roofs

• Affordability: Asphalt shingles are significantly more budget friendly upfront. 
• Ease of Installation: Most contractors are skilled at installing shingles, reducing the labor time and costs. 
• Traditional Look: Shingles deliver timeless appeal loved by many homeowners.

Key Differences Between Metal Roofs and Shingles

• Durability: It lasts 40 to70 years, while shingles need replacement in 15 to 30 years.
  
• Installation: Shingles are quick and easy to install, while metal requires skilled labor and more time.
  
• Cost: It has a higher upfront cost but saves money long term with fewer repairs and better energy efficiency.
  
• Energy Efficiency: Metal reflects heat, keeping your home cooler, while shingles absorb heat, increasing cooling costs.
  
• Weather Resistance: Metal roof withstand wind, hail, and fire, while shingles can be damaged in extreme weather.

Metal vs. Shingle Roof: Pros and Cons

​When choosing between a metal roof and shingles, it’s essential to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each option.

Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs

Pros

• Longevity: Lasts 40–70 years, sometimes even longer.
  
• Durability: Can withstand extreme weather conditions, including heavy winds and hail.
  
• Energy Efficiency: Reflects solar heat, reducing cooling costs by 10–25%.
  
• Low Maintenance: Requires minimal upkeep.
  
• Environmentally Friendly: Often made from recycled materials and fully recyclable.

Cons

• Higher Upfront Cost: More expensive than asphalt shingles.
  
• Complex Installation: Requires specialized skills and experienced metal roof installers.
  
• Noise Factor: Can be noisier during rain or hail unless properly insulated.

Pros and Cons of Shingle Roofs

Pros

• Affordability: Lower upfront cost.
  
• Easier Installation: Can be installed quickly by most roofers.
  
• More Style Options: Available in various colors and designs.
  
• Easier Repairs: Individual shingles can be replaced if damaged.
  

Cons

• Shorter Lifespan: Typically lasts 15 to 30 years.
  
• Prone to Damage: Can be affected by extreme heat, moisture, and strong winds.
  
• Less Energy Efficient: Absorbs heat, leading to higher cooling costs.
  

Metal Roof Versus Shingle Roof – Which Offers Better Value?

Energy Efficiency and Insulation

• Metal Roofs reflect sunlight, reducing cooling costs.
  
• Shingles absorb heat, leading to higher summer energy bills.
  

Lifespan Comparison

• ​Metal Roof: 40 to 70 years.
• Shingles: 15 to 30 years.

Resale Value and Market Appeal

• Homes with metal roofs often have higher resale value due to their longevity and modern appearance.
  
• Shingle roofs are still widely accepted but may not add as much value to resale prices.
  

Homeowners Associations Typically Require Asphalt Shingles

If you live in a neighborhood with a Homeowners Association (HOA), you might be required to use asphalt shingles.

• Many HOAs prefer shingles because they blend in better with other homes in the community.
  
• Metal roofs, while durable, may not meet HOA aesthetic guidelines.
  
• Before choosing a metal roof, check your HOA’s regulations to avoid fines or required replacements.
  

However, some HOAs are becoming more flexible as they gain popularity for their energy efficiency and durability.

Metal Roofing Performs Better in Most Types of Extreme Weather

One of the biggest advantages of metal shingles roof is its ability to withstand extreme weather conditions. Whether it’s fire, hail, tornadoes, hurricanes, or floods, a metal roof provides better protection for your home.

Wildfire Protection

If you live in a wildfire prone area, a metal roof is the safest option.

• Non combustible: They have a Class A fire rating, meaning they won’t ignite from flying embers.
  
• Shingles, especially wood based ones, can catch fire easily, increasing the risk of damage.
  

Hail Resistance

Hail can cause significant damage to asphalt shingles, but metal holds up much better.

• Metal roofs resist denting and cracking, especially high-gauge steel and aluminum panels.
  
• Some metal roofing panels are even rated for severe impact resistance, making them ideal for hail prone regions.
  

Tornado Durability

During a tornado, strong winds can rip shingles off a roof, leaving your home vulnerable to leaks and structural damage.

• It can withstand wind speeds of up to 140–160 mph, making them much stronger than traditional shingles.
  
• With proper installation, a metal roof can survive severe storms with minimal damage.
  

Hurricane Protection

If you live in a hurricane zone, metal roofing is the safest choice.

• It is designed to resist high winds, withstanding gusts over 150 mph.
  
• Shingles can easily lift and tear off in hurricane force winds, leading to costly damage and leaks.
  

Flood Resistance

While your roof may not be directly impacted by floodwaters, the right roofing material can help protect your home during heavy storms.

• It sheds water more efficiently, reducing the risk of leaks.
  
• Asphalt shingles can absorb moisture, leading to mold growth and rot over time.
  

In extreme weather conditions, a metal roof is the superior choice, offering better protection, durability, and peace of mind.

Metal Roofs Are More Compatible with Solar Installations

If you're planning to install solar panels, a metal roof is the best choice.

• Easier Installation: Solar panels can be mounted directly onto metal roofs without drilling into the surface, reducing the risk of leaks.
  
• Longer Lifespan: Since its last 40+ years, they won’t need replacing before your solar panels wear out, unlike shingles.
  
• Energy Efficiency: It reflects heat, improving the efficiency of your solar energy system.
  

Shingles, while compatible with solar panels, require more maintenance and may need replacement before your solar system does, adding extra costs.

Metal Roof Installers

How to Choose a Reliable Metal Roof Installer

• Check certifications and experience with metal roofing.
  
• Read customer reviews and testimonials.
  
• Ask for warranty information on installation and materials.
  
• Compare quotes from multiple installers to get the best deal.
  

Average Labor Costs for Metal Roof Installation

DIY vs. Professional Installation Considerations

• Metal roofing requires expertise, and improper installation can lead to leaks.
  
• Shingles are easier to install DIY, but professional work ensures longer lasting results.
  

Metal Roof vs Shingles Cost

A major consideration when comparing metal roof vs shingles cost:

• Metal Roof: The metal roof cost vs shingle roof cost skews higher primarily due to both the price of metal roofing panels and the specialized labor required. However, with a lifespan of 40 to 70 years, it often pays off as a long term investment. 
  

Shingle Roof: Asphalt shingles are among the most affordable roofing materials on the market. While the cost to replace them every 20 to 30 years adds up, they still remain a lower cost choice upfront. ​

Example

• Average metal roofing panels cost per square foot (materials): $5 to $14 (location dependent). 
  
• Asphalt shingles average cost per square foot (materials): $1 to $4.
  

While metal roofs are pricier upfront, they often have lower long term costs due to minimal maintenance and their extended lifespan. Ultimately, the cost of metal roof vs shingles​ comes down to your long term goals and budget.

Metal Roof Cost vs Shingle Roof Cost: A Detailed Comparison

One of the biggest questions homeowners ask when choosing between metal roof shingles is, "How much will it cost?"

Average Pricing for Both Materials

The cost of a roof depends on material type, labor, and installation complexity. Here’s a rough breakdown:

• A metal roof costs $5 to $18 per square foot, so for a 2,000 sq. ft. home, you’re looking at $10,000 to $36,000 in total.
  
• A shingle roof is cheaper, costing $3 to $6 per square foot, meaning a 2,000 sq. ft. home would cost $6,000 to $12,000.
  

Factors Affecting Cost

• Material Choice: Steel roof that looks like shingles, aluminum, and copper roofs have different pricing.
• Installation Complexity: It requires skilled labor, increasing installation costs.
• Location & Contractor Availability: Prices vary based on region and demand.

Cost of Metal Roof vs. Shingles – Which is More Affordable?

Short Term vs. Long-Term Affordability

• Short-term: Asphalt shingles are cheaper to install.
• Long-term: Metal roofs have lower maintenance costs and a longer lifespan.

Metal Roof Pricing Breakdown

When considering metal roof pricing, homeowners can expect to pay:

• Material Costs: $4 to $10 per square foot
• Labor Costs: $3 to $7 per square foot
• Additional Costs: Fasteners, underlayment, flashing

Shingle Roof Pricing Breakdown

• Material Costs: $1 to $3 per square foot
  
• Labor Costs: $2 to $4 per square foot
  
• Additional Costs: Roof deck repairs, ventilation
  

Can You Put a Metal Roof Over Shingles?

Thinking about upgrading to a metal roof but dreading the messy, expensive process of ripping off your old shingles? Good news you can install a metal roof over shingles, and in many cases, it’s a smart move! 
Why It’s a Great Idea

• Saves Money: No need to pay for labor and disposal costs to remove the old shingles.
  
• Less Mess & Faster Installation: Keeps your yard shingle free and speeds up the project.
  
• Extra Insulation: Shingles provide an additional layer that can help reduce noise and improve insulation.
  

Conclusion: Which Roof is Right for You?

So, metal roof or shingles, what's the best choice for your home? Well, it all comes down to your budget, long term goals, and the climate you live in.
If you’re looking for a quick and affordable roofing solution, asphalt shingles are a great option. They’re easy to install, budget friendly, and available in many styles. But keep in mind, they need more maintenance and usually last only 15 to 30 years before needing replacement.
On the other hand, a metal roof is a long term investment that offers superior durability, energy savings, and weather resistance. While it costs more upfront, it requires less maintenance and can last a lifetime. If you're considering solar panels, metal is the best option for easy installation and efficiency.
Ultimately, the best roof for you depends on whether you prioritize lower upfront costs or long term savings. No matter what you choose, hiring a professional installer ensures a stress free experience, fewer repairs, and a roof that keeps your home safe for years to come. If you're still unsure, consult a local roofing expert to find the perfect fit for your home!

FAQs